Sklansky's Analysis on Policing in the United States
David Alan Sklansky in his Democracy and the Police (Stanford University Press, 2008) asks an interesting question: everyone praises "democratic policing" and condemns the "police state," but what do these terms actually mean? He concludes that the relationship between democracy and policing has been theorized far too loosely, and that getting it right requires tracing how changing ideas about democracy have shaped and been shaped by the changing ideas about the police.
It must be mentioned in the beginning that he deals with policing in the United States. He identifies three stages of policing in the United States.
Political patronage policing (roughly the 19th century to the early 20th century). American police forces were decentralized, controlled by local ward politicians, and riddled with corruption, brutality, and patronage — jobs and promotions traded for political loyalty, enforcement directed at the enemies of the machine. Early police reformers attacked this system using the emerging language of democratic pluralism: the danger was not the state as such but captured, partisan government, so the cure was to insulate the police from politics.
Professional, "pluralist" policing (circa the 1930s–1960s). The professional era — think Sergeant Friday of Dragnet, the emblem of just-the-facts policing — created centralized, bureaucratically managed, technocratic departments: civil service recruitment, training, crime statistics, and insulation from ward bosses. Sklansky calls this "pluralist policing" because it mirrored democratic pluralist theory: police, like other professional state agencies, should be neutral instruments serving a public defined as competing interest groups, kept legitimate by efficiency and legality rather than community ties. By the 1960s this model lost faith and legitimacy — "pluralism's fall" amid urban unrest, scandals, and criticism of police remoteness.
Community policing (from the late 1970s onward). As pluralist democracy gave way to participatory and deliberative ideals, the new orthodoxy became community policing — foot patrols, neighborhood partnerships, responsiveness to local voices, "public safety as community empowerment."
His core historical claim concerns the last half-century of American history. He identifies two parallel stories usually told separately: the story of democratic theory's evolution, and the story of policing reform. On the democratic side, the mid-twentieth-century consensus — pluralist democracy, in which politics is competition among organized interest groups brokered by professional elites — collapsed under critique, giving way to participatory and deliberative ideals that emphasize citizen engagement, community involvement, and face-to-face discourse. On the policing side, the postwar model of professional law enforcement — centralized, bureaucratic, technocratic, insulated from political interference, and measured by crime rates and clearance statistics — likewise lost legitimacy, displaced by the new orthodoxy of community policing, with its rhetoric of partnership, foot patrols, neighborhood input, and responsiveness to local concerns.
Sklansky's contention is that these two transformations are deeply connected: the shift from professional policing to community policing tracked the shift from pluralist to participatory democracy. Community policing advocates sold their reforms in managerial and crime-fighting terms (better intelligence, more trust, lower crime), but the deeper appeal was democratic — the promise of returning police to the people. Yet, he argues, the fit between democratic theory and policing strategy has never been one-to-one, and uncritical celebration of community policing obscures real tensions.
That tension is the perhaps book's most significant insight. Community policing, in practice, has frequently empowered the already powerful within neighborhoods — homeowners, older residents, business owners — while marginalizing young people, renters, minorities, and the unhoused. Participatory policing can thus produce local tyranny rather than democratization: aggressive order-maintenance campaigns against "disorderly" populations pursued in the name of community preferences. Sklansky shows that pluralism's defects (elite domination, apathy) and participation's defects (exclusion, parochialism) each map onto characteristic policing failures, and no single democratic theory delivers a police that is simultaneously effective, fair, and accountable. Deliberative democracy, he suggests, offers more promising resources — policing decisions subjected to genuine public reasoning that includes those most affected — but nothing resembling a guarantee.
The book's second half tests this richer, messier conception of democratic policing against concrete controversies:
- Racial profiling — reframed not simply as ineffective law enforcement or rights violation, but as a democratic failure: policing that treats some citizens as less than full members of the political community.
- Private security — the rapid privatization of policing, usually discussed as a problem of accountability and equality, seen here through the lens of democratic theory: private policing privatizes a public function, thinning the shared civic space that democracy requires.
- Affirmative action in police hiring — analyzed as a question about the composition of the police and its bearing on representativeness and legitimacy, rather than merely litigation strategy.
- Internal governance — how departments manage themselves (disciplinary systems, managerial hierarchies) is a democratic question, since police organizations model, or fail to model, the values they enforce.
Sklansky insists that policing is not merely an instrument evaluated by crime statistics but a constitutive democratic institution, the state's most intrusive daily contact with citizens, whose character expresses what kind of democracy we have. Reform debates should therefore be conducted in explicitly democratic vocabulary, with all its complexity, rather than disguised as merely as an exercise in crime-control.